18 November 2011
Afan Lido: Chris Curtis, Daniel Sheehan, Craig Hanford, Liam Hancock, Carl Evans, Kristian James, Carl Payne (Adam Llewellyn 88′), Jonathan Hood (Jackson Hall 83′), Mark Jones (Daniel Thomas 78′), Andy Hill, Leon Jeanne
Unused Subs: Michael Davey, Alex Gammond, Carl Heffy
Yellow card: Hill 69′
Goals: Carl Payne 16′ 57′, Jonathan Hood 41′
The New Saints: Paul Harrison, Barry Hogan (Mattie Williams 46′), Phil Baker, Steven Evans, Scott Ruscoe (Aeron Edwards 59′), Tom Roberts, Chris Marriott, Connel Rawlinson, Greg Draper, Alex Darlington (Nicky Ward 46′), Craig Jones
Unused subs: Charlie Proctor, Chris Williams, Marcus Giglio, Alex Ramsey (gk)
Yellow card: Baker 67′
Goal: Greg Draper 18secs
Attendance: 267
Referee: Dean John